Park Avenue Long Lasting Eye Contour Liner Eyeliner

I bought this pencil as an alternative to Artdeco pencils (shades 11, 12) that I have been using for several years. Lately, the Artdeco pencil has significantly lost its quality - it's too soft, needs frequent sharpening, breaks easily, smudges, etc. That's why I decided to try this one. The pencil shade is 03 Brown. It's a brown shade, not dark, but closer to the color of milk chocolate. The pigmentation of this shade is weaker compared to the Artdeco pencil. If we compare it to Artdeco shades, this shade is in an intermediate position between 11 and 12 in terms of brown tones. The pencil doesn't have shimmer. It draws well on the eyelid without scratching it, but the lead is harder than Artdeco pencils. It stays on well throughout the day, the shade doesn't fade for 8 hours, and the winged eyeliner in the corners of the eyes doesn't smudge or flake off. Overall, it's a good pencil, especially considering the price (I bought it on sale). I can recommend it.